TL;DR
A 2019 analysis by Transport & Environment estimated that Carnival Corporation’s cruise ships emitted nearly 10 times as much sulphur oxide around European coasts in 2017 as Europe’s 260 million cars. The comparison concerns estimated emissions in that year, not a current measurement; the source material does not provide the report’s full methodology or later figures.
A 2019 analysis by Transport & Environment (T&E) estimated that Carnival Corporation cruise ships emitted nearly 10 times as much sulphur oxide (SOx) around European coasts in 2017 as the region’s 260 million cars. The comparison highlights cruise-ship air pollution, but it describes estimated emissions in a past year, not a current measurement.
Get travel and outdoor gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
The analysis, described by Ecohustler, ranked Carnival, then identified as the world’s largest cruise operator, as the cruise company with the highest SOx emissions around European coasts. It said Royal Caribbean Cruises ranked second, with emissions estimated at four times those of the European car fleet. The source does not include the underlying emissions totals or detailed calculation methods.
T&E also estimated that cruise ships’ European nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions equalled about 15% of those from passenger cars across Europe in a year. In Marseille, it said 57 cruise ships emitted almost as much NOx in 2017 as one-quarter of the city’s 340,000 passenger cars. Those figures are estimates attributed to the report, not independently documented measurements in the material provided.
The report identified Spain, Italy and Greece as the countries most exposed to cruise-ship SOx pollution in absolute terms, followed by France and Norway. It named Barcelona, Palma de Mallorca and Venice as the most affected port cities, followed by Civitavecchia near Rome and Southampton. These rankings concern the report’s assessment of emissions and exposure, not a complete comparison of residents’ total pollution exposure.
Pollution Near European Ports
Sulphur oxide emissions matter because they contribute to sulphate aerosols, which can harm human health, and to acidification in land and water environments, according to the source. Cruise ships can emit pollution while sailing near populated coastlines and while docked, making port cities part of the debate over how to reduce transport emissions.
The comparison also raises a regulatory question: road vehicles and ships operate under different rules and conditions, so the figures do not by themselves show that cruise ships cause more total harm than cars. They do, however, point to a potentially substantial source of emissions concentrated around particular coastal areas. T&E argued that governments should set stricter limits rather than rely on cruise companies to make changes voluntarily.
Products Worth Considering

DJI Mini 3 Fly More Combo with DJI RC

DJI Mini 4K Drone with 4K UHD Camera

GoPro LIT HERO Waterproof Action Camera with Built-In Light
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Rules T&E Wanted Changed
Ecohustler’s 2019 article said it had challenged Carnival shareholders at the company’s annual general meeting in April, urging pollution reductions, including through cleaner fuel. The subsequent T&E analysis focused on cruise-ship emissions around Europe in 2017, comparing those estimates with emissions from the European passenger-car fleet.
At the time of the report, the source said emission control areas covered the North Sea, Baltic Sea and English Channel, but not the rest of Europe’s seas. T&E recommended extending those areas, regulating NOx emissions from existing ships, and adopting zero-emission standards for ports. It also pointed to shore-side electricity, batteries for shorter routes and hydrogen as possible technologies. These are recommendations and statements made in the report, not evidence that the measures were subsequently adopted.
Limits of the 2017 Comparison
The source material does not provide the report’s full methodology, emissions totals, uncertainty ranges or the precise boundaries used for “around European coasts.” It also does not explain how the car and cruise-ship figures were calculated or whether they account for differences in where and when emissions occur. The headline comparison should therefore be read as an estimate reported by T&E, not as a direct measurement of relative health impact.
The figures are for 2017 and the article appeared in 2019. No newer emissions data, current company ranking, subsequent regulatory decisions or response from Carnival is included in the supplied material. The report’s exposure rankings also do not establish that any named city had the highest overall air pollution or health burden.
Current Emissions Data Needed
To establish how the cruise sector’s emissions compare today, readers would need newer data and the full methodology behind the estimates, alongside information on fuel use, ship activity and applicable regulations. The source material does not identify a follow-up report or a timetable for the policy changes T&E proposed.
The recommendations set out in 2019 included extending European emission control areas, regulating NOx from existing ships and requiring zero-emission standards at ports. Whether governments or cruise operators have since adopted those measures is not established by the material available here.
Key Questions
What does the nearly 10-times figure compare?
It compares T&E’s estimate of Carnival cruise-ship SOx emissions around European coasts in 2017 with emissions from Europe’s 260 million cars. It is not a current emissions figure.
Which cruise company ranked second in the analysis?
The 2019 account said Royal Caribbean Cruises ranked second, with estimated SOx emissions four times those of the European car fleet. The supplied material does not include the detailed calculations.
Which places did the report identify as most exposed?
It named Spain, Italy and Greece, followed by France and Norway, among the most exposed countries in absolute terms. Barcelona, Palma de Mallorca and Venice were listed as the most impacted port cities, followed by Civitavecchia and Southampton.
What policy changes did Transport & Environment recommend?
T&E called for zero-emission standards at ports, broader European emission control areas and NOx rules for existing ships. These were recommendations in the report; the supplied source does not confirm whether they were later implemented.
Source: ecohustler.com
